This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The Maze: A resale sale can replace a new clothing purchase or become an extra purchase. Those two outcomes count equally in a platform’s sales report but have different implications for demand for new clothing. WRAP’s UK research estimates what buyers would otherwise have bought. It offers a way to discuss substitution without claiming that researchers counted garments removed from factory orders.

Source claims 35 in 100 secondhand purchases replace nothing new; underlying WRAP weighted displacement rate is 64.6%.
  • 👕 Replacement has to be estimated. WRAP reports a 64.6% UK weighted displacement rate for resale. Displacement means a used purchase replaces a new one. Responses contribute different weights depending on the buyer’s alternative. The weighted result is more informative than assuming every resale purchase substitutes for a new item. It cannot identify which individual orders prevented any new buying.

  • 🧮 The remainder is calculated. The original post says roughly 35 in every 100 do not replace a new purchase. That shorthand rounds 35.4%, calculated as 100 minus 64.6, rather than counting a separate group of orders. A buyer can give an answer that is weighted as partial substitution. That is why the complement cannot be reported as a tally of known transactions with no environmental benefit.

Our take: Keep the volume of secondhand transactions separate from the share estimated to replace new buying.

  • 🔁 Measure substitution alongside sales. WRAP defines displacement around a purchase that would otherwise have been made new. Ask buyers what they would have done without the used option; sales growth alone cannot distinguish replacements from extra purchases. A platform may improve the availability of close used substitutes, or it may attract shoppers looking for an extra bargain. Report the assumptions and period alongside the estimate so partners can tell which behaviour the survey is intended to measure.

  • 🏭 Keep factory claims separate. TexSPACE highlights the distinction between displaced purchases and avoided production. A brand claiming manufacturing savings needs evidence that its orders to suppliers fell, plus a separate assessment of transport and use. A decline in new demand only changes production if suppliers adjust output. Even then, delivery, subsequent use and what sellers buy with the proceeds are separate mechanisms. Neither the sales total nor the displacement rate supplies that calculation.

Share this story

Share on FacebookShare on XShare on LinkedIn

Was this useful?

Login or Subscribe to participate