This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The Maze: A shopper sees a brand on TikTok, searches for it later and buys it at Target. In this hypothetical journey from Peter Quadrel, founder of Odylic Media, one channel gives the shopper a reason to look and another helps close the sale. Quadrel calls those jobs demand creation and demand capture. His framework gives brands a way to plan campaigns by job. To decide what to fund, a brand still needs to learn whether the discovery ads bring in sales it would otherwise miss.

Odylic groups connected TV, YouTube, TikTok, Meta, AppLovin and creators as mainly creating demand, and Google Search, Amazon Ads and retail media as mainly capturing it. Channels can do both.

The details

  • 🎬 Plan by the job you want the ad to do. Quadrel groups nine channels by their primary demand role. He puts connected TV (ads shown on streaming television), YouTube, TikTok, Meta, AppLovin and creators mainly on the creation side. He puts Google Search, Amazon Ads and retail media mainly on the capture side. Retail media is advertising sold by retailers. Each channel can do both jobs. A social ad can remind someone who has already browsed, for example. The grouping is a practitioner's framework with no measured shares, market, study period or sales results.

  • 🛒 The purchase and the discovery can show up in different reports. Quadrel’s TikTok-to-Target example illustrates a problem for brands that sell through retailers as well as their own site. The retailer records the purchase, while the brand's TikTok report may show the ad view without a sale attached to it. That makes the ad easy to undervalue. The reverse mistake is also possible. More searches for the brand or more units sold after a campaign can reflect a promotion or other changes. Both signals can guide a test.

Our take

Before moving budget between discovery and purchase-focused ads, give the campaign a sales test that includes the places where shoppers can actually buy.

  • 🧪 Hold back the discovery ads in comparable regions. To test whether a campaign like the one in Quadrel’s example adds sales, compare regions where the campaign runs with similar regions where you hold it back. The second group is the holdout. Look for similar sales patterns before the test and keep search ads, prices and promotions as comparable as you can. Check store stock, too. A shortage in one group can distort the comparison. The test needs enough sales to detect a meaningful difference and limited exposure to the campaign in holdout regions. Decide which storefronts can supply usable regional sales before you start.

  • 📦 Count units and first-time buyers separately. A retailer's store sales report can count units without identifying who bought. If reliable regional figures are available, use those units to see whether the campaign helped sell more products at that retailer. A shopper can buy several units or return for another purchase. Count first-time buyers separately wherever you have purchase history that can establish whether someone is new, such as on your own site. A buyer new to your site may already buy the brand at a store. Report the scope of each result so a lift in retail units does not get mistaken for growth in the customer base.

Share this story

Share on FacebookShare on XShare on LinkedIn

Was this useful?

Login or Subscribe to participate

Reply

Avatar

or to participate